Chemical vs Physical filters
CHEMICAL FILTERS
Oxybenzone, Avobenzone, Dioxybenzone, Sulisobenzone, Octinoxate, Cinoxate, Homosalate, Octisalate, Trolamine Salicylate, Octocrylene, Ensulizole, Padimate O, Iscotrizinol, Phenylbenzimidazole Sulfonic Acid, and PABA (Para-Aminobenzoic Acid), Meradimate.
1. Avobenzone
Harm to the body:
- Unstable under UV exposure – breaks down into toxic compounds.
- May cause skin irritation and allergic reactions.
- Can contribute to free radical formation.
Harm to the environment: - Toxic to marine life and coral reefs, causing degradation.
2. PABA (Para-Aminobenzoic Acid)
Harm to the body:
- Known strong allergen; can cause contact dermatitis.
- Associated with phototoxic reactions.
- May disrupt hormonal balance.
Harm to the environment: - Toxic to aquatic organisms and marine ecosystems.
- Banned in some countries due to environmental harm.
3. Cinoxate
Harm to the body:
- May cause allergic reactions and skin irritation.
- Not stable under sun exposure.
Harm to the environment: - Water-soluble, accumulates in water bodies, negatively affecting ecosystems.
4. Dioxybenzone
Harm to the body:
- Hormone disruptor (endocrine disruptor).
- Can cause irritation and phototoxic reactions.
Harm to the environment: - Negatively affects marine flora and fauna.
5. Ensulizole
Harm to the body:
- Can irritate skin, especially for sensitive individuals.
- Weak UVA protection, making it less effective.
Harm to the environment: - Toxic to aquatic organisms when it enters oceans.
6. Homosalate
Harm to the body:
- Accumulates in body tissues.
- Endocrine disruptor, affects hormones.
- May cause skin irritation and phototoxicity.
Harm to the environment: - Toxic to aquatic ecosystems and contributes to coral reef degradation.
7. Meradimate
Harm to the body:
- Limited effectiveness against UVB rays.
- May cause skin irritation in sensitive individuals.
Harm to the environment: - Mild but cumulative toxic effect on marine life.
8. Octinoxate (Ethylhexyl Methoxycinnamate)
Harm to the body:
- Disrupts hormonal balance by mimicking estrogen.
- Found in bloodstream and breast milk.
- Causes phototoxic reactions and allergies.
Harm to the environment: - Causes coral bleaching and death.
- Toxic to marine flora and fauna.
9. Octisalate
Harm to the body:
- May cause allergic reactions in sensitive skin.
- Unstable under prolonged sun exposure.
Harm to the environment: - Accumulates in water bodies; harmful to aquatic life.
10. Octocrylene
Harm to the body:
- Breaks down into benzophenone, a toxic and potentially carcinogenic substance.
- Causes allergies and skin irritation.
- Penetrates the bloodstream and accumulates in tissues.
Harm to the environment: - Toxic to corals and marine life; accumulates in the aquatic environment.
11. Oxybenzone
Harm to the body:
- Strong endocrine disruptor, affects hormonal systems.
- Found in blood, breast milk, and urine.
- Causes irritation and phototoxic reactions.
Harm to the environment: - One of the main contributors to coral reef destruction.
- Toxic to marine ecosystems even in small concentrations.
12. Padimate O
Harm to the body:
- Can break down under UV exposure, forming free radicals.
- Causes allergic and phototoxic reactions.
Harm to the environment: - Negatively affects aquatic ecosystems and marine life.
13. Sulisobenzone
Harm to the body:
- Penetrates the skin and accumulates in tissues.
- May cause irritation and phototoxic reactions.
Harm to the environment: - Hazardous to aquatic environments; toxic to marine organisms.
14. Trolamine Salicylate
Harm to the body:
- May cause skin irritation and allergic reactions.
- Not well studied for long-term health effects.
Harm to the environment: - May accumulate in aquatic environments and negatively affect marine life.
Overall Harm of Chemical Filters:
- Hormonal Disruption: Many filters are endocrine disruptors, affecting sex hormones, the thyroid, and overall hormonal balance.
- Body Absorption: Most chemical filters are absorbed through the skin and detected in blood, breast milk, and urine.
- Skin Allergies and Irritation: Can cause dermatitis, redness, itching, and rashes.
- Phototoxicity and Free Radicals: Under sunlight, they may degrade into toxic compounds and free radicals, accelerating skin aging.
- Environmental Harm: When washed off into water, they cause coral bleaching, reef death, and disrupt ocean ecosystems.
Conclusion:
Most chemical filters in sunscreens pose toxic risks to both human health and the environment. They may disrupt hormones, cause allergic reactions, accumulate in the body, and contribute to coral reef and aquatic ecosystem destruction. Physical filters based on zinc oxide and titanium dioxide offer a safer alternative for both skin and planet.
PHYSICAL FILTERS
Physical (mineral) filters are natural inorganic compounds that form a protective layer on the skin, reflecting or scattering UV rays (UVA and UVB). They are considered safer than chemical filters but have certain specific features and contraindications.
1. Zinc Oxide
How it works:
- Forms a thin film on the skin that physically reflects UV rays.
- Provides broad-spectrum protection from both UVA and UVB.
Benefits and effects on the body: - Hypoallergenic and safe for sensitive skin.
- Has anti-inflammatory properties and is commonly used in creams for irritated skin (e.g., baby creams).
- Does not penetrate deeply when in non-nano form.
- Safe for pregnant and breastfeeding women and children.
Contraindications: - Nano-form zinc oxide may penetrate the skin and raise concerns about particle accumulation. Choose non-nano formulations.
- May leave a white cast on the skin, especially at high concentrations.
Environmental impact: - Safe for coral reefs and marine organisms.
- Does not degrade into toxic compounds in water.
- Unlike chemical filters, does not cause coral bleaching.
2. Titanium Dioxide
How it works:
- Creates a protective layer on the skin that reflects and scatters UVB and some UVA rays.
- Mainly protects against UVB but, when combined with zinc oxide, offers full-spectrum protection.
Benefits and effects on the body: - Well tolerated by sensitive skin, hypoallergenic.
- Non-irritating, suitable for people with dermatological conditions.
- Like zinc oxide, remains on the skin surface and is barely absorbed (if non-nano).
Contraindications: - Titanium dioxide nanoparticles may enter the body through damaged skin or inhalation (e.g., in sprays), raising safety concerns.
- Risk of respiratory irritation when used in sprays or powders.
- May leave a white residue on the skin.
Environmental impact: - Considered safe for coral reefs and aquatic life.
- However, in sunlight, nano-form titanium dioxide can produce reactive oxygen species (ROS), which in high concentrations may be toxic to marine organisms.
- To minimize risk, use non-nano titanium dioxide.
3. Natural oils with SPF protection
…
Conclusion:
Zinc oxide and titanium dioxide are safe and effective alternatives to chemical filters. Non-nano forms provide strong UV protection without harming human health or marine ecosystems.
INNER PROTECTION
…
1. Zinc
How it works:
- …
2. Vitamin D
How it works:
- …
3. Magnesium
…
Conclusion:
…